Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Well, today I got a case where the buzzing happened, but the system kept going (and still is after hours). What I noticed was that the driver/device kept being "busy" when I tried to deactivate it via device-manager (Windows asked to reboot).

I turned the driver back on (Windows asked to reboot again) and plugged out the cable (bus-power = turned off the FF). After plugging the cable back in Windows would not detect the FF even while the red HOST led does not light up.

So obviously the driver got totally shot down and needs a reboot, but the fact that it didn't freeze the computer is interesting. This time I used the FF for gaming and Teamspeak with the FF being setup as default Windows output device.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I've not always had it crash when it began buzzing. If I managed to close the app and disconnect the Fireface in time, the system would be fine even if from that point on the Fireface was non-usable. I haven't really tried to get it playing again without a reboot too much mainly because it'd crash.

Also: Forgot this in my photo montage. Just for the sake of completeness, this is what I'm testing with, even though hardware has been ruled out.
[img align=c]http://spiraling.org/rme/part-three.jpg[/img]

53 (edited by Timur 2010-02-03 10:18:01)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I did not disconnect the FF though (and in the past that lead to freezes anyway) and the computer is still running after more than 10 hours now.

Uninstalling the FF and FW drivers did not help to make the FF reappear (before rebooting). Interestingly the FW driver can be deactivated/uninstalled/changed without Windows asking for a reboot. This means that it is *not* in use even when the FF is plugged in.

54 (edited by Timur 2010-02-03 10:46:24)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I noticed that the Fireface keeps being listed as "Capture" device in the Registry and that its security policies cannot not be changed nor can it be deleted (HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\MMDevices\Audio\Capture).

By disabling the Windows Audio service the Fireface related entries are deleted by Windows and don't come up again.

Another problematic registry entry is: HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\ControlSet002\Control\DeviceClasses\{6994AD04-93EF-11D0-A3CC-00A0C9223196}\##?#1394#A35&2#000A35011FDB96B9#{6994ad04-93ef-11d0-a3cc-00a0c9223196}

Even taking ownership of that entry is restricted. Other ControlSet entries for the FF400 were no problem.

PS: I still did not reboot Windows yet since the buzzing happened.

55 (edited by Timur 2010-02-03 11:14:17)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Ok, I'm currently using the FF400 successfully again (no buzz, no freeze, no bs for about 15 minutes). I do have several suspicions but like to go through them one by one.

First do set the onboard audio as system default, *not* the FF, so that you can make some settings without a freeze.

Here is the first thing I'd like you to try: *Read* the flash settings from the FF via Fireface Settings. Mine turned out to be quite messed up (no options set, no SPDIFout options set , buffer set to 48 samples). Turn on all options except for "Interleaved", turn on all SPDIFout except for "non-audio", set buffer to 256 samples. You might try different clock settings (auto, master). Then *write* the flash settings back into the FF.

After that do a reboot, *read* the flash settings to check they are correct and report back if it works.

56 (edited by November 2010-02-03 12:34:30)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Well, looks like I do get to be a bit more useful here with my background. What you're seeing in regedit is due to the fact that Windows locks away control on those keys to the 'TrustedInstaller' user by assigning them ownership. This is part of their security model by basically throwing up a roadblock to prevent rogue processes run by an Administrator account from going hog wild, but it's actually easy to override.

Just go to the Permissions box, click 'Advanced' and then go to the 'Owner' tab and switch ownership to the 'Adminstrators' group while making sure you tick on the option to push this change to all subcontainers and objects, then apply. Flip over to the 'Permissions' tab and then edit the Administrator's group, ticking on 'Full Control'. Make sure 'Replace all child objects yada yada' is also checked on, else you still can't delete or edit the child objects. Presto, now you can delete and alter these keys all you want. In theory you should never have to do this since driver installers/uninstallers provided by the vendor due to being signed or using pnputil would be able to take these actions on your behalf, but we live in an imperfect world.

I'll be posting a follow up in a bit when I get to play with the FF400s downstairs without disturbing anyone sleeping. I might risk sneaking it since I'm up late anyway.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I got my 400 yesterday and have similar problems. I have win 7 (x64). while playback i had lots of cracks. then i deinstallted the nvidia drivers which helped a bit, cracks only all 30 seconds. but i also have a lot of cracks when recording my axe fx ultra (guitar multi effect) via spdif. i played with the samples and i get cracks under 256 samples, which is very annoying because i hat a motu mk iii hybrid before and i had no cracks and a latency of about 3ms at 96 samples. i always read that the rme 400 is the lowest latency device on the market, and now this... :-(

it has obviously something to do with the drivers. so can somebody of rme give an offical word on it? are the aware of the problem and will they fix it?

otherwise will go back to motu soon...

cheers,
dan

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Danny, you are experiencing drop-outs which are likely caused by some misbehaving *other* driver. Look for the "100 us DPC Latency..." thread in the Tip & Tricks forum to get an idea of what you have to do about your crackling problems.

59 (edited by November 2010-02-03 13:11:44)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I've decided that my quest to solve this mystery meant that I pretty much did exactly what you suggested right as soon as I hit 'post' on my last post.

Initial read:

http://spiraling.org/rme/flash-one.png

Set to:

http://spiraling.org/rme/flash-two.png

Rebooted and when I read it back the settings persisted.

Now, I've done this as well as set the default playback device to integrated, nothing else. When I loaded Foobar2000 and set the output to the monitoring channels and played back a track, it played fine for several minutes before the buzzing kicked in. It's still buzzing right now (I've turned down the volume) and I've not locked up.

What's more interesting is that Foobar2000's spectrum meter was vibrating/twitching back and forth like it was looping between a few samples. I try shifting the playback bar about and scrubbing and it does change the shape of the spectrum readout even if the buzzing isn't interrupted, but it's completely wedged at that point as if it cannot play back further at all.

Closing the application now, the buzzing stops. I can hear however a slight hiss over my headphones from the Fireface. Opening Foobar2000 again and playing the same track again, it's playing normally but I hear absolute silence. The spectrum meter is bouncing, the timeline is moving and for all intents and purposes it believes everything is fine. It's still set to output over Analog 7+8. Meanwhile, in the Fireface mixer it has zero evidence of anything being played back even though Foobar seems to think everything is fine. The Out 7 + 8 are dead, nothing is moving.

I've not touched anything further than this by the time of my posting, other than obviously opening up my browser and pasting what I wrote in Notepad (paranoid I'd lock up at any moment and lose my notes).

EDIT: With the mixer open, I can adjust the pot on the Fireface and watch it adjust the sliders in the mixer application. So it's obviously responding somewhere.

60 (edited by Timur 2010-02-03 13:16:19)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

The "loop" experience is correct, because the "buzzing" is the Fireface playing it's last sample-buffer in a loop, which often happens when an audio driver crashes.

My system is playing properly for 2 hours now. I used Media Player Classic for video playback and Eve Online for game playback on analog Stereo 1+2. I'm letting Foobar2000 1.0 (basic install with no add-ons or prefs changes) run now.

The Registry/ownership stuff was clear to me, but there were several similiar entries that I could get access to while I could not take ownership nor administrator access for the quotes ones.

If I understand correct you did not get a Blue Screen / Freeze this time?

What you can try next is to uninstall both the Fireface and Firewire drivers via device-manager (unplug FF), then manually search for all "Fireface" entries in the Registry and delete them (unless you cannot take ownership) and also make sure both Fireface dlls and exe files are deleted from Windows\system32. Then do a reboot, have Windows rediscover the Firewire port and then connect the FF. Windows will likely automatically install the FF driver, let it, but after that manually update the driver to the latest 2.9992.

Please test with Stereo 1+2 instead of 7+8 first (use Totalmix to route 1+2 to 7+8 or even better, use Preset 1 and maybe even store that to the FF's flash). Only if that works try 7+8.

61

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

November, Emphasis should not be checked on the SPDIF output unless you play back material that has been equalized accordingly.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Jepp, I didn't care for what the option does, just tried to make sure we use the same options. smile I will switch off Emphasis to get to even grounds.

Foobar is playing for 1h30m now and to make things more interesting I started Ableton Live 8.1.1 MME/DirectMusic Playback, Windows Media Player and Media Player Classis on top of it, all playing back on Channel 1+2.

I noticed that Live cannot access any other outputs in this configuration even with Interleave disabled, the audio engine stops right away (and turns back on once I switch back to 1+2).

63 (edited by November 2010-02-03 15:50:42)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Unfortunately before I saw your reply, I attempted playback for a third time in Foobar2000. This time I got audio playback again, followed by the buzz, then the crash. I've heard audio drivers crash before, but usually I'm used to hearing slight pitch variation or something a bit more reminiscent of what's being fed into the device -- but yeah, you're right that it's being trapped on the sample.

At this point I did walk away for a while so I apologize for the delay in my reply. Anyway, here goes...

I've been able to take control of all the keys that I wanted to via the post I mentioned *including* the enumerated keys and entries created for ControlSet* which is usually handled by removing the Fireface via Device Manager. Though sometimes this does not happen like it should when you remove devices. You gotta struggle a bit because part of the child keys inside these keys actually have no permissions on them at all for you to even view them period. You gotta expand the trees and find these keys and try to push down ownership repeatedly until you hit the bottom of the tree, while assigning yourself full control before you can delete them. Try deleting a key you added yourself as owner/full control to and you'll notice it'll refresh and suddenly be expandable with more formerly hidden keys beneath it. Trust me, with some finesse you can nuke all of this without even having to boot into Safe Mode or otherwise try and force Windows to give up its hold on these entries. It just sucks at recursively assigning yourself ownership *and* then the right to even view the child keys to then go and assign ownership further down.

Anyway, I've removed every trace of the Fireface 400 drivers from both the system and the registry, in addition to nuking the cached drivers (what Windows tries to automatically reinstall with) using pnputil and then rolled a brand new fresh installation after a reboot.

On a lark, I went to Fireface Settings and it did not have any of the previous settings set. I hit Read Flash Memory and OK'd out of it.

(By the way, MC, I'm just syncing to what Timur had set, Emphasis was not set prior when I was having these issues. Though I am curious why you honed in on that screenshot and not the 17 other posts I've made in this thread? Anyway, I've unchecked it now regardless.)

EDIT: -- Ignore the following crap below because I am an idiot and it's 6:45 AM and I need to sleep soon. I'm keeping the following two paragraphs because it might amuse someone.

Here's where we get to an interesting problem. There isn't an Analog 1+2 output anywhere. Not in Control Panel/Sound, not in Foobar2000. I've got Analog 3 through 8, SPDIF, ADAT 1 through 8, etc. Everything that should be there other than AN 1+2 for Playback. It actually DOES exist for recording/input. On OS X, this is certainly not the case. If this functions different on Windows, I'm totally unaware (and mind you, I've not had a chance to find out given this issue). I honestly haven't noticed if it was like this before during my other ordeals and trials.

I've tried routing the other channels (3+4, etc) and playing with Foobar, but I hit the buzzing issue every time. Anyway, if you can confirm if my missing AN 1+2 is odd or not, that'd probably help a good bit (Again, I've not used this really EVER under Windows, so I don't know if this is normal or not, nor do I have the Fireface manual on hand at the moment).

EDIT: It was staring me in the face. It's Speakers, isn't it? I'll mess with that soon and see if it changes, but given everything else looks bugged, I'm not optimistic.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Yes, Analog 1 + 2 is the "Speaker" output, which is why I suggested trying this first (it's obviously a "special" case output for Windows).

I did try getting down to the subtrees in registry by the way and several other ControlSet keys did not need any policy changing at all. Anyway I'm back to stable playback even with several keys and the driver cache left behind so I guess it's not too important.

Another thing you should try next is to download NVidia's latest chipset driver directly from the NVidia site. You find them under Nforce -> Series 7 -> 730i/9400M. Don't install the Ethernet/LAN managment suite though (but do install the driver).

If that doesn't work you will have to try my oddest suggestion: If you are using W7 Ultimate then download the german language pack and set Windows' "Display Language" to german. Do a reboot after that (not just a relogin).

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I've tried the Speaker output, same buzzing result.

Good to hear the registry is irrelevant, now if we could only figure out where stuff is going wrong.

I'll try giving the chipset update a go, though usually those filter drivers aren't too too terribly important beyond killing Windows installs dead after a motherboard swap.

If that doesn't work you will have to try my oddest suggestion: If you are using W7 Ultimate then download the german language pack and set Windows' "Display Language" to german. Do a reboot after that (not just a relogin).

This actually made me laugh, but I know where you're going with this. I often (though not currently) usually have my default fallback language set to Japanese to fix certain programs. I'll actually give it a go just because my German is terrible (I actually did study it!) and it'll be fun to test.

Unfortunately all of this will have to wait now. The sun is up and I really need to get some sleep. Thank you for your help so far, Timur. I'll try to get back to this thread when I've had more time to try things out.

66 (edited by Timur 2010-02-03 16:44:31)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Another thing you should try is to set the Windows Speaker settings to 48 kHz for the Fireface's stereo output (will only allow 16 bit, while the UC also allows 24 bit) and try to disable exclusive access.

The language suggestion might be odd, but changing language from german to english was one of the very few things I changed before my own Fireface startet to blue screen/freeze/buzz, so you never know what oddities work under the hood of the OS. ed:

PS: I'm currently running english again without problems, but still we have to go through whatever helped my system get back on its feet. I even could switch to ASIO playback in Live while both media players and Foobar kept running (switched to exclusive ASIO mode) and back to WDM without a hickup.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Okay, some good tips to play with! (Yes, I'll be going to bed shortly, but I suddenly wanted to test something out first!)

Both Jeff Petersen and several others here have mentioned DPC Latency Checker a few times. I've decided to go pretty hog wild with this,
despite the fact I have some reservations about the idea of latency causing a bluescreen:

http://spiraling.org/rme/latency-one.png

First I've disabled pretty much *everything* I could even remotely think of safely disabling. I even rolled back to the VGA driver after that screenshot, rebooted *and* killed BootCamp.exe after booting into glorious 800x600. I've made sure to include every device I've disabled in that screenshot just for fun.

http://spiraling.org/rme/latency-two.png

This ran for a while. There's no spikes whatsoever past green. Now I closed the app, made sure the Fireface 400 was hooked up, Speaker was the default output device and I fired up an mp3....

http://spiraling.org/rme/latency-three.jpg
http://spiraling.org/rme/latency-four.png

So it looks like whatever this is isn't latency related or related to any of the devices I disabled, which is damn near everything. I'll be trying your suggestions next, but I figured I might as well get this big one out of the way first.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

radiation wrote:

Thanks you Robert!

I did changed the registry on windows 7 but steelthe same. Where can i stop Windows Media Player Network Sharing Service? or Windows Endpoint Builder Service?

Thanks,
George

Hi George,

You both find them in the services applet. Right click my computer - Choose manage and find the services. First stop the service and after that disable it.
Suc6.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Today I had the Blue Screen problem popping up again. Which is a good thing, because it gives me another opportunity to try some things out.

The only thing that should have changed on my setup between my last successful use (last monday) and today was the installation of Office 2010 Beta (which I had installed and uninstalled on that machine before).

One thing since monday is that I repeatedly send the MBP/Windows 7 to sleep via closing the lid. Interestingly Windows 7 by default send the computer into Hybernation (suspend-to-disc) even when the settings were set to *Standby* (Safe Power). I reset the settings back and forth and now Windows properly uses Standby instead.

There may be some connection between Sleep mode and the problem, especially when knowing that the NVidia chipset came with an updated "Sleep Mode" driver. Seeing how there are issues in connection with sleep on OS X as well it's at least something to take a look at. DeadHorse

70 (edited by November 2010-02-08 20:06:34)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I'm afraid I've been a bit too busy to try any of your suggestions lately, sorry -- but I did have time to check in. Windows does sleep the laptop on close, though sometimes it likes to suddenly wake itself up for reasons unknown, but it also did that on my mid-2007 MacBook Pro as well. Will try updating the chipset filter driver at some point to see if that corrects that issue alone, though I am doubtful it'll fix the FF400 issue I have over here.

I diiiid get an email reply from RME support saying that supposedly RME engineer folks are reading this thread, even if none have commented. That's actually good enough for me at the moment because given that there's a number of threads about this very subject and the ample amount of evidence there's some kind of problem, even if where exactly hasn't been found -- just having word that someone from RME's engineering team has seen this means I'm pretty okay with the situation for now.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Hi guys
Did anybody made Windows 7 and FF400 work right?
I have tried everything you guys wrote on this forum but still have the same high latency on DPC.
Please anybody knows something?
We could also use Teamviewer so you check my system your own.
Thanks,
George

72 (edited by radiation 2010-02-14 18:18:23)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Hi Timur

Here is DPC on Windows Xp x86 sp3
[img align=c]http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z303/GEORGEVASILAS/WindowsXp.jpg[/img]
Here is DPC on Windows 7 x86 Utimate
[img align=c]http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z303/GEORGEVASILAS/Windows7.jpg[/img]


Why Why Why???? What is the problem???

Anyone from RME with a new idea?

My system once again:

Processor
Model : Intel(R) Core(TM)2 Extreme CPU X9650  @ 3.00GHz

System
Mainboard : Gigabyte Technology EP45T-EXTREME

Video System
Adapter : ATI Radeon HD 4870 X2  (1GB, PCIe 2.00 x16, PS3.0, VS3.0)

Storage Devices
WDC WD740ADFD-00NLR1 74GB (SATA150, NCQ, 16MB Cache) : 69GB (C:)
WDC WD5000ABPS-01ZZB0 500GB (SATA300, 3.5", 5400rpm, NCQ, 16MB Cache) : 466GB (D:)
WDC WD3200YS-01PGB0 320GB (SATA300, 3.5", 7200rpm, NCQ, 16MB Cache) : 298GB (E:)
PIONEER DVD-RW  DVR-216D (SATA150, DVD+-RW, CD-RW, 64kB Cache) : N/A (G:)

Peripherals
FireWire/1394 Controller 1 : VIA VT6306 VIA Fire II IEEE-1394 OHCI Link Layer Controller
FireWire/1394 Controller 2 : Giga-Byte TSB43AB23 1394a-2000 OHCI PHY/link-layer Controller

I have installed fut_win_fire400 1.67, 1.69, 1.70
And w2fire_2993, 2998, 29991.
I did tests between the drivers and firmware but i still have the same problems on Windows 7 x86 & x64 and Vista x86 & x64.

So is there enybody with the same problem solved??? or will it ever be?

Anyone from RME can tell me what to do?

What is the secret of Windows Xp and it works so smooth without crackles and pauses???

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

HI,
this is common with older laptops
this has to do with ACHI/IDE modes.
if the laptop has the option for ACHI it might work but it will break the XP install.
conversely newer laptops cant install XP generally.

Scott
ADK

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

radiation wrote:

Why Why Why???? What is the problem???

Bad driver, maybe bad BIOS. Sorry, but blame your laptop. Try to find drivers in Microsoft's "Update Catalog" and even try them if they are older than the ones you've got.

75

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Installed my FF400 to a Win7 x64 system this past weekend after getting tired of all the blue screens I was getting on shutdown using a tascam fw1884.  Had much better success after borrowing the ff400 from my mobile rig.  My system is an Intel 975bx2 mobo with a q6700 processor and 8 gigs ram oc'd to 3.2 ghz using mostly Sonar x64.  It's actually been running many years under xp64 using the tascam interface but I just upgraded it to Win7 x64 (fresh install to a new c: ssd boot  drive) last week.

Installed the ff400 29992 drivers and flashed to 1.70.  Had previously set the Windows sound scheme to "No Sounds" and shut off the start-up sound.  Also previously reflashed the Intel mobo with the latest bios, installed all of Intel's newest infs, and did all my Windows updates.

I have always used WDM/KS in Sonar but the ff400 spidif interface kept getting reported by the rme driver as a 16-bit device. Fired up Reaper x64 and it got the same info from the ff400 driver.  I use spidif for my hardware reverb unit and 16-bit truncation before mixdown wouldn't be good for me.  Switched to asio and that seems to be good. Only issue was shelling out of the daw to edit audio clips with SoundForge... asio doesn't share well.  Got around that by giving SoundForge Analog 3/4 (daw uses Analog 1/2) and routing it in the Matrix to the same outs as 1/2.  And all is well.

I did experience a bit of a problem doing a spidif-send to my reverb unit and recording its spidif-out.  Got allot of crackling and popping.  Turned out I had to shut off write-caching in Sonar which I never did with my tascam unit.  No big deal once I guessed the solution.  I was able to get 2 solid days of work done this past (us holiday) weekend on an 88.2k/24-bit project without any major incidents. So far, so good.

I have the buffer-size set to 128, nothing checked on spidif-out, everything checked on options, and dds-disabled.

Howard

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Fuck it guys! I'm going back to XP!

Thanks for your time Timur

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

My pleasure! :-D wink

78 (edited by yannick dc 2010-02-18 19:19:38)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

i got the same problem...
but when i deactivate the wifi & geforce, the dpc latency checker says it should be able to handle real time audio.
now its still not working like it should (yes it's better but i mean wtf...) i don't hear crackles anymore, but now every ca 15 sec it hackles.
so what now? xp?
so if i dualboot win7 & xp it should work?
because i don't wont to format my win7

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

If you are on a laptop turn off the "ACPI Comliant Battery" thing via device-manager.

80 (edited by yannick dc 2010-02-18 20:27:52)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

tried it, but it still hackles(skip) & sometimes cracks
what i don't understand is that dpc checker looks just fine....
anyway thanks

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

If your problems are happening with DAW software then either try deactivating Aero or manually setting the priority of the software to "Realtime" (start Task-Manager "as Administrator" to do that or turn off UAC).

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

no i got the problem all the time, not only in ableton

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

The priority problem is not a problem of Ableton, but of nearly all current DAW software. They all use the same *non*-realtime priority that Aero uses. The only exceptions I know about are Sonar (MMCSS) and Samplitude (highest *real*time priority as an option). With Live it's easy to fixvia Task-Manager

But if you also got the problems with Windows Media Player then the problem lies somewhere else.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

yesterdag i installed windows xp en tried it.... i need to say "it sounded a LOT better" but still some pauses (skip) but no crackles en no panic
so obviously it's something with the laptop.

85 (edited by Timur 2010-02-28 09:45:27)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Timur wrote:

Today I had the Blue Screen problem popping up again. Which is a good thing, because it gives me another opportunity to try some things out.

Something interesting happened: for the second time now my Macbook Pro frooze without having any external audio interface attached or even playing back any audio/video. But the behvaior was *very* similiar to how video-playback crashed/frooze with the FF400 before.

In these situations the display was put to standby (black screen) while Windows kept working on some simple downloads in the background. I moved the mouse to wake up the screen. Windows stopped responding to any input (including CTRL-ALT-DEL), but the mouse was still moving. Then, after a couple of seconds, the whole system froze (no BSOD).

Even alot worse than what we experienced with the FF400: Windows could *not* be started anymore except for Safety-Mode, not even from the Installation CD! Removing the graphic-driver via Safety-Mode did not help. The startup process would either halt after the Windows 7 boot-loader animation (where the 4 colored dots form the Windows logo) or the screen would remain black.

Now comes the interesting part:

1) Starting into OS X and then rebooting back to Windows (Bootcamp) made Windows work again. After that I switched the NVidia driver back to the one shipping with Bootcamp, but the freeze happened a second time sometime later.

2) Since the last crash (BSOD) with video-playback via the FF400 I did not have time to check it again, but after the second non-playback freeze I not only started into OS X, but also reset the PRAM/NVRAM. Now I checked video playback via Media Player Classic over the FF400 and no crash happened.

Since November is using a bootcamped Mac, too, I am very much inclined to suspect a Mac specific problem!

@November: Please do a PRAM/NVRAM reset (http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1379) and try again. If you didn't start into OS X for some time then also try that.

86 (edited by yannick dc 2010-02-28 21:21:50)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

my problem is solved, but i bought a macbook pro and i not bootcamped it because i like the mac os....

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

I had more bootcamped Windows 7 freezes on my Macbook Pro 17" 2009 and it turned out that reseting the PRAM/NVRAM does not help to make Windows boot again (not even the recovery enviroment can be loaded), but only starting into OS X helps.

Unfortunately I did not have any other FF400 related crashes yet, so I could not test if there is any relation between the two.

88

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Not sure if this is related, but Windows 7 definitely behaves differently to previous versions. After a crash chances are quite high that it does not boot at all. It stops directly after BIOS. You have to use the Win DVD and repair start errors. I never found out what exactly gets repaired, but I had to do this so often that I decided to have a rescue USB stick with me that does the same as the Windows recovery CD (which can be made from within Windows, so you don't have to carry the original with you).

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Nubie here.

+1 for bootable USB with O\S
In my experience (using win7 since the first rc's), hidden partition that is installed with Win7 is a bad idea. If the files here are damaged, it will never boot.
I never install with hidden partition (google) How can Acronis (or any other) make a full image to restore if it is not included? Maybe someone knows that answer?
I have had the same problem as Matthias, many times, long time ago. It was due to bad ram corrupting the files on the hidden partition (Memtest86+) and believed my HDD's were failing.
No problems at all 24\7
Dedicated PC's for audio. (Fireface 800 Win7x64)

I hope this can help someone with similar problems. Best regards.

90

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Now this is off topic, but Acronis (like others) have no problem to backup that 'hidden' partition. And I had W7 installed without that hidden boot partition too - same error. The most annoying thing was to transfer the Recovery CD to the USB stick - there is no option in Windows to create the recovery files on a bootable stick directly. rant

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

91 (edited by menathor 2010-03-05 05:56:09)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Hi all,

Thought I'd share some info with all of you re: my FF 800 bluescreen problems (sorry if this is a double post from my other thread, but it seemed relevant - maybe the other post should be deleted).

I run Win 7 64bit (not via bootcamp - I have a PC) and the RME drive has been causing bluescreens on a regular basis. I'm running the latest firmware and 2.9992 driver (problem was still occurring with the older driver too). Reinstalling Win7 hasn't helped.

The error that is displayed is IRQL_NOT_LESS_OR_EQUAL or IRQL_GT_ZERO_AT_SYSTEM_SERVICE (kicking myself that I didn't write down exactly which one....). But I do have my crash dump files, and when I analyse them, the error is occurring in audiodg.exe every time.

The reason I'm fairly certain it's the RME drivers is because when I go into Sounds in control panel and disable all the RME ins and outs in Windows, the crashes stop occurring. I'm still able to use the Fireface in applications that use the ASIO driver, but not in those that use that go through the normal windows sound drivers.

For the others who are experiencing these bluescreen errors, have you tried downloading the window debugging tool and analysing the crashdump .dmp files in your c:\windows\minidump directory? Posting the results may help RME get to the pottom of this? If everyone's error has the same cause, it means it's a non-system-specifc driver problem that needs to be fixed.

Here is the analysis of my latest crash dump (they all report the same error). It's a raised IRQ fault - possibly related to switching from ASIO usage to normal windows driver usage (eg. using Cubase, then trying to run something like Media Player). But I'm just guessing.




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Microsoft (R) Windows Debugger Version 6.11.0001.404 AMD64
Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.


Loading Dump File [C:\Windows\Minidump\022510-51870-01.dmp]
Mini Kernel Dump File: Only registers and stack trace are available

Symbol search path is: SRV*c:\Symbols*http://msdl.microsoft.com/download/symbols
Executable search path is:
Windows 7 Kernel Version 7600 MP (8 procs) Free x64
Product: WinNt, suite: TerminalServer SingleUserTS
Built by: 7600.16385.amd64fre.win7_rtm.090713-1255
Machine Name:
Kernel base = 0xfffff800`02a68000 PsLoadedModuleList = 0xfffff800`02ca5e50
Debug session time: Thu Feb 25 03:35:55.284 2010 (GMT+11)
System Uptime: 0 days 16:24:08.110
Loading Kernel Symbols
...............................................................
................................................................
...........................................
Loading User Symbols
Loading unloaded module list
............
*******************************************************************************
*                                                                             *
*                        Bugcheck Analysis                                    *
*                                                                             *
*******************************************************************************

Use !analyze -v to get detailed debugging information.

BugCheck 4A, {7759ff2a, 2, 0, fffff88013483ca0}

Probably caused by : ntkrnlmp.exe ( nt!KiSystemServiceExit+245 )

Followup: MachineOwner
---------

3: kd> !analyze -v
*******************************************************************************
*                                                                             *
*                        Bugcheck Analysis                                    *
*                                                                             *
*******************************************************************************

IRQL_GT_ZERO_AT_SYSTEM_SERVICE (4a)
Returning to usermode from a system call at an IRQL > PASSIVE_LEVEL.
Arguments:
Arg1: 000000007759ff2a, Address of system function (system call routine)
Arg2: 0000000000000002, Current IRQL
Arg3: 0000000000000000, 0
Arg4: fffff88013483ca0, 0

Debugging Details:
------------------


PROCESS_NAME:  audiodg.exe

BUGCHECK_STR:  RAISED_IRQL_FAULT

FAULTING_IP:
+0
00000000`7759ff2a ??              ???

CUSTOMER_CRASH_COUNT:  1

DEFAULT_BUCKET_ID:  VISTA_DRIVER_FAULT

CURRENT_IRQL:  2

LAST_CONTROL_TRANSFER:  from fffff80002ad9469 to fffff80002ad9f00

STACK_TEXT: 
fffff880`13483a68 fffff800`02ad9469 : 00000000`0000004a 00000000`7759ff2a 00000000`00000002 00000000`00000000 : nt!KeBugCheckEx
fffff880`13483a70 fffff800`02ad93a0 : fffffa80`0a56b3e0 00000000`01e1fc58 fffff880`13483bc8 00000000`00000001 : nt!KiBugCheckDispatch+0x69
fffff880`13483bb0 00000000`7759ff2a : 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 : nt!KiSystemServiceExit+0x245
00000000`01e1fc28 00000000`00000000 : 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 00000000`00000000 : 0x7759ff2a


STACK_COMMAND:  kb

FOLLOWUP_IP:
nt!KiSystemServiceExit+245
fffff800`02ad93a0 4883ec50        sub     rsp,50h

SYMBOL_STACK_INDEX:  2

SYMBOL_NAME:  nt!KiSystemServiceExit+245

FOLLOWUP_NAME:  MachineOwner

MODULE_NAME: nt

IMAGE_NAME:  ntkrnlmp.exe

DEBUG_FLR_IMAGE_TIMESTAMP:  4a5bc600

FAILURE_BUCKET_ID:  X64_RAISED_IRQL_FAULT_audiodg.exe_nt!KiSystemServiceExit+245

BUCKET_ID:  X64_RAISED_IRQL_FAULT_audiodg.exe_nt!KiSystemServiceExit+245

Followup: MachineOwner
---------

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

MC wrote:

Not sure if this is related, but Windows 7 definitely behaves differently to previous versions. After a crash chances are quite high that it does not boot at all. It stops directly after BIOS. You have to use the Win DVD and repair start errors.

Problem in my case is that you cannot even boot from the DVD (only safety-mode works). I very much suspect something getting messed up with EFI or the NVidia graphic BIOS, because starting into OS X solves the problem at once.

Currently I am testing two things:

1. Turning off display standby (because most of the freezes happened after awaking the display).

2. Turning off harddrive standby (the Seagate 7200.4 sometimes makes erratic noise that is connected to its energy saving modes).

I'm still hoping to get another FF400 related BSOD/freeze so that I can check the connection. Fact is that I had the BSOD thing first not happening, then happening, then not happening, then happening and now it didn't happen even after several days of regular Media Player Classic (ffdshow audio filter) usage.

93 (edited by Timur 2010-03-07 15:07:08)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Here is one interesting Windows system log entry concerning Windows 7 Sleep/Standy on a Macbook Pro 17" 2009:

The platform firmware has corrupted memory across the previous system power transition.  Please check for updated firmware for your system.

That was at 3:22 in the night when I send the system to sleep/standby. At around 10-11 in the morning I restarted the computer and used it for about 2 hours without problems (no FF connected).

Then I connected the FF400 and my external projector to the computer and it crashed (connecting an external display before did not crash it, so I suspect the FF400 connection to be the culprit). After a restart I could use the FF400 for normal playback via Windows Media Player and Media Player Classic without problems.

The computer has rebooted from a bugcheck.  The bugcheck was: 0x0000001e (0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000000). A dump was saved in: C:\Windows\MEMORY.DMP. Report Id: 030710-23290-01.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Today I got an IRQL_GT_ZERO blue screen about 1-2 minutes after plugging in the FF400 (just when I turned on the hifi that the FF400 was connected to). Interestingly it happened again shortly after connecting the Macbook Pro to the projector, on the other hand I did that successfully several dozend times before.

Unfortunately the MBP booted into OS X right afterwards (I turned it off during the white screen with the animated circle). After rebooting into Windows the problem did not happen again (played several video files) but I cannot say if halfway booting into OS X is connected to this.

Have to keep watching...

PS: No freezing of the MBP since I turned off the display and HD standby options. But have to let it run for a few more days.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Some additional information about the latest BSOD crash:

After restarting Windows 7 the FF400 was *not* detected eventhough the HOST light on the FF was not lit (at least I didn't notice). I turned the FF off and on again (bus-powered via backside switch), heard the Windows Hardware detection sound and everything worked again.

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

menathor wrote:

I run Win 7 64bit (not via bootcamp - I have a PC) and the RME drive has been causing bluescreens on a regular basis. I'm running the latest firmware and 2.9992 driver (problem was still occurring with the older driver too). Reinstalling Win7 hasn't helped.

The error that is displayed is IRQL_NOT_LESS_OR_EQUAL or IRQL_GT_ZERO_AT_SYSTEM_SERVICE (kicking myself that I didn't write down exactly which one....). But I do have my crash dump files, and when I analyse them, the error is occurring in audiodg.exe every time.

...

Here is the analysis of my latest crash dump (they all report the same error). It's a raised IRQ fault - possibly related to switching from ASIO usage to normal windows driver usage (eg. using Cubase, then trying to run something like Media Player). But I'm just guessing.


---------

Hi all,

There are two FF800's in my Asus P6T / i7 / Win7 64 bit system.  I have had same problems as you - same blue screens, especially IRQL_GT_ZERO_AT_SYSTEM_SERVICE, that are somehow FF800 related. Blue screens happen usually after I have closed Cakewalk Sonar (8.5.3) and try to play music with Winamp. 

Blue screen has never happened in Sonar but ASIO driver may hang for minute or two few times a day. Trying to start playback after hang-up will always lead in stuttered sound (or no sound at all even if the playback seems to be on).  And now if I close Sonar and start Winamp or any other program that does not use ASIO then Windows will go to blue Blue Screen immediately. 

System:

Intel Core i7 950 3,06GHz          
Asus P6T -ATX-emolevy LGA1366
OCZ Gold Low Voltage Triple Channel 6GB             
Asus EAH4350 SILENT/DI/512MD2(LP)
Antec Sonata III 500 - ATX, 500W     
Samsung SH-S222A/RSMN musta/valkoinen/ho         
Sunix Firewire 400/800 2 x Beta, 2 x 6-p         
    
2 x Fireface 800

Windows 7 64 bit Home Premium

I hope RME founds solution to this problem.

sonarmods.com

97 (edited by menathor 2010-03-12 06:53:58)

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

panu wrote:

There are two FF800's in my Asus P6T / i7 / Win7 64 bit system.  I have had same problems as you - same blue screens, especially IRQL_GT_ZERO_AT_SYSTEM_SERVICE, that are somehow FF800 related. Blue screens happen usually after I have closed Cakewalk Sonar (8.5.3) and try to play music with Winamp.

@panu -  This is EXACTLY the same issue I'm having (happens in the same kind of situation too). Could you try a couple of things and let us know the results? Firstly, try going into Control panel - Sound and disabling all FF inputs and outputs from "Playback" and "Recording" tabs (they will disappear from the list). Basically, the idea is to make sure Windows isn't using the FF for anything. To work around getting sound from your windows applications, you could run sound out of the digital or analogue out of your motherboard's onboard soundcard into the inputs of the FF (this is what I'm currently doing). Also, Sonar will still work since disabling the FF ins and outs in Windows Sound will not disable the ASIO driver.

If this works for you as a fix (it did for me) - can you report back and let us know?

Also, it would be great if you could download the Windows 7 Debugging Tool (http://www.microsoft.com/whdc/Devtools/ … fault.mspx) and analyse your crashdump file (it will be the latest .dmp file inside the c:\windows\minidump directory). This will allow you to check whether the problem was with audiodg.exe, as it was with me.


@MC - it seems I'm not the only one having this bug - could you let us know if it is something that is being looked into for the next driver update?

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Hi menathor,

I disabled all FF i/o in Control Panel - Sounds yesterday. Now I'm waiting for the results.
Btw, I had one blue screen when I went to Inputs tab in Contorl Panel / Sounds. This has happened several times before.

Now I need ASIO compatible video and WAV/MP3 players. Any suggestions?
There is an ASIO plugin for Winamp but it crackles sometimes.

sonarmods.com

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Best bet would be to install the drivers for your onboard soundcard - the Asus P6T has an onboard Realtek ALC1200 chip (if it is disabled in bios, re-enable it). Once this is enabled, set Windows -> Sounds to the onboard sound input and output. Then, you'll need to run an optical cable from the output of the Realtek (i.e. on your motherboard's back panel) to the ADAT2 input on the FF, and switch "SPDIF IN" in the FF Settings window to "ADAT2". Your other alternative is to get a 3.5" stereo to 2 x 6.5" mono cable and run the analog out of our Realtek into 2 of the analog inputs of the FF.

Volume is then controlled via the respective inputs in Total Mix. Eg. need to route the SPDIF input to analog 1 and 2 (or whatever outputs your speakers are connected to).

It's a pain in the behind workaround, but most importantly - it works. Since I've done this, my computer has gone from crashing every 1 to 2 days to staying on 24/7 and not having crashed once in 2 weeks. Look forward to hearing your results.

P.S. Are we going to get any kind of acknowledgement from RME that there's an issue here? No replies from anyone yet - to my forum post or to my email to support??

P.P.S. I wonder if this is just an issue with Win 7 64bit and not with 32bit?

100

Re: FF400 and Windows 7 will it ever work right??????

Now I've managed to use my DAW two days without BSOD's.
It seems that disabling sounds in control panel is workaround.

However, Sonar 8.5.3 (both 32 and 64 bit versions) are more likely to get problems with RME ASIO driver in Windows 7 64 bit than in XP 32 bit. For example, enabling or disabling input echo may cause audio driver hang and 'motorboat'. Also arming a track may freeze Sonar for a minute. 

Currently my ASIO buffer size is 96.
128 works worse and lower stress too much CPU in large projects.

sonarmods.com