Topic: THD dummy vs headphone load
Another independent review of the ADI-2 DAC has surfaced: https://www.audiosciencereview.com/foru … -dac.2582/
The first page contains standard measurements with dummy loads and the measurements are very good, just as expected.
Things get more interesting on page 5, where the headphone output's THD+N is measured under real world headphone loads, which is not normally done. Then THD+N increases significantly. It seems to correlate with THD caused by the headphones tested: When testing the ADI-2 DAC with high distortion Grado headphones, distortion measured at the headphone output is much higher than when testing low distortion Hifiman headphones.
I don't want to insinuate that this is out of spec (the specifications are based on resistive dummy loads) or audible (-60 dB THD is unlikely to be an issue when your Grados come with -15 dB). There are a few more amps tested in this thread in later posts, and they all do worse than the ADI-2 DAC. My interest in this is purely technical and I have a few questions about the observed behavior:
1. Is there a layman explanation as to what is happening here when measuring with real headphone loads, and why do amplifiers measure so differently? Another amp reaches -37 dB where the ADI still manages -63 dB.
2. Is this something coming from the amplifier, fed into the headphones (in this case it could be audible if the distortion becomes sufficiently large) or merely the analyzer measuring the headphones distortion?
3. Benchmark allege that it is possible to reduce this distortion to be almost unmeasurable with their amplifiers (linked on page 5), likely based on a TI whitepaper which is linked on page 7. Do you consider such a design beneficial and would you consider it for future products?