unpluggged wrote:trubadix wrote: My first concern was primarily the inability to do bass management for more than the stereo channels - hence this post!
This concern is only valid for analog monitors. In case of network-enabled monitors like your KH 150, the bass management is implemented with these speakers' DSP, so there is no such limitation. MA 1 supports multichannel configurations, and bass management is, of course, available for them. All you need is a set of network-enabled Neumann speakers, a KH 750 DSP subwoofer, the MA 1 kit and the additional MA 1 Multichannel extension (which is a separate purchase, but the price is reasonable and it more than worth it): https://www.neumann.com/en-gb/products/ … -for-ma-1/
Wait, I think we are on to something here! Either of us is misunderstanding something about MA 1's capabilities and I hope it is me! So, let me go back a few steps to figure out what happens with bass management and what MA 1 can and can't do there:
For bass manegenemt I am looking for an ideal cut off frequency for each satellite that the speaker is either no longer able to produce with the required volume or in some cases for matters concerning room acoustics where the speaker cannot be placed to a position to produce that lower frequency properly and the subwoofer is. But regardless of the reasoning, bass management means to redirect lower parts of the signal for each satellite to one or more subwoofers. These subwoofers can be exclusively for that type of function or they double as the LFE in a multi-channel system.
With that in mind, let us look what the Neumann DSP line of speakers can do here: there is an important distinction between the AES67-versions and all other version of the KH-DSP line. The AES67 get audio via ethernet cable, all other versions get the audio via analog input or SPDIF. That means, the ethernet port on the non-AES67 versions are not transferring any audio. They are just there for configuration purposes. As soon as you have have done the calibration and uploaded all of the profiles to these speakers, they no longer require the ethernet connection. And that means (unless I understood that wrong) there is no way for any of those to redirect audio coming to the speaker (regardless whether it is analog or digitally via SPDIF) to the subwoofer. With the AES67 variants it could be possible in theory, but it is not. Bass management with the AES67 is possible with the Neumann Audio interface, though, but as I am going to stay with RME, I did not go for the AES67-versions.
If I am not wrong, you mistakenly assumed that MA 1 was doing any bass management, which it does not! In fact, when you you careful read in the description, the word bass management is only used there, because the KH 750 does it and when you use it, you can use MA 1 on two non-DSP monitors like KH 310:
https://www.neumann.com/de-de/produkte/ … ries/ma-1/
I would be a happy man, if what you suggest would be possible right now. But from my understanding, it is only possible to do bass management before the analog or digital connection to the speaker. And that is why the two options I am looking at are either doing it in the RME interface with total mix or routing all analog (or or potentially digital outs) to a DSP powered Neumann Sub that is not released as of yet. Having DSP on the Sub would only help with alignment and room EQ as long as it is not a newly designed Sub that would just receive all speaker inputs and act as kind of a hub for the full monitoring system. But even with such a hub, the ethernet port of a KH 150 still could not receive any audio signal via the ethernet port unless it is the AES67 version.