Topic: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Hi

Hope someone can give guidance. I've connected my Multiface II via a Sonnet card chassis to my 2014 macbook pro running Big Sur.

The installation of drivers went smoothly, TotalMix and the DSPe settings app are present and run. Behaviour of the MF seems as I remember it from my 2011 MBP, which had a card slot. The MF powers up, flashes until the card is connected. In my case today, this does happen and TotalMix and the DSPe settings apps open as soon as I connect the Sonnet to the thunderbolt port.

However! Despite switching my DAW and system outputs to the Hammerfall, no audio is moving through the system. There is zero activity on the TotalMix channel strips. After restarting the machine with everything connected, the TotalMix was suddenly maxed out on all channels as if there was some massive feedback loop with no daw or sound activity from the system - but there was still no audio being pushed to the monitors. Disconnecting and reconnecting the interface via the DSPe settings seems to have reset the system and we're back to zero activity.

I'm also getting no audio from the headphone output.

Very confused, and i need to get this up and running.

Thanks for any advice

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Try firmware update

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

3

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

You use the HDSP ExpressCard? With which firmware version?

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

4 (edited by Anthony H 2023-12-20 19:52:23)

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

MC wrote:

You use the HDSP ExpressCard? With which firmware version?

Yes I'm using the card.

Not sure where to see the firmware version. In HDSPe Settings/About it's got Mac OS X driver version 4.13 and Multiface (serial number) Rev. 18

Edit - I have updated the firmware to 20 and the Driver to 4.24, and it doesn't seem to have helped. In fact, my system crashed once when trying to play an audio file. Help please?

I am inserting a screengrab of totalmix so you can see what I mean. Analog 1&2, SPDIF, ADAT all going nuts, except Analog1/2 OUT which is silent.

https://i.ibb.co/x2w3FgK/Screenshot-2023-12-20-at-20-46-30.png

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

I am experiencing full system panic crashes. This has not happened on this machine before today, after hooking up the Multiface.
This is just from trying to preview a wav file using the space bar in finder to test audio - it doesn't play even one second before crashing. I don't have any DAW or other audio applications open.

The crash log includes this:

loaded kexts:
com.RME.driver.HDSPMADI    4.13

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Audio preview in Finder has been broken for years, I don't think you can consider that part an RME issue.

What about using a regular audio player app?

Regards,
Jeff Petersen
Synthax Inc.

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

I've never had an issue with using space bar to playback files in Finder - it's a handy tool.

I've tried a standalone instance of Kontakt and I've tried VSTs in Cubase - silence. Until it starts doing the thing in the image above which I can only compare with feedback. I forgot to mention that when this happens there IS sound - a high pitched tone. This is why the software output analog 1/2 is muted in TotalMix. I can't remember now if the Analog Hardware Outs are showing nothing because I muted the Software outs, or if they were showing nothing irrespective of the muting. I'll have to check tomorrow again. I've checked the analog inputs and those seem to be working fine - i can see the levels moving up and down on the input channels.

I have a deadline approaching so this is becoming quite stressful.

8

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

What you experience is nothing else than hanging communication between hardware and driver. It could be the ExpressCard, the Sonnet adapter, the TB cable...even the Multiface. I see no way to easily find the cause as you need to replace each single item (up to the computer) to find out where exactly it fails.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

I'm sure you'll understand when I say that is a completely unsatisfactory response. The Sonnet and Thunderbolt cable are brand new. The idea that one should need to somehow source a second Multiface and ExpressCard (and computer!) to diagnose a problem is not only impractical, it's simply not possible.

I have a feeling the answer may lie in the drivers. Can anyone indicate which drivers and firmware are optimal for this setup?

Is it possible that the problem could lie in the power supply? I have had to use a different psu, which has worked perfectly, after the RME supply just died for no reason.

10

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Anthony H wrote:

I'm sure you'll understand when I say that is a completely unsatisfactory response.

I don't.

Anthony H wrote:

The Sonnet and Thunderbolt cable are brand new.

Which does not guarantee that they are compatible to a 15 year old HDSPe DSPe Express card. I don't know if they are, Sonnet most probably also doesn't know. There are several 'versions' of PCI Express, and these caused incompatibilities with some Sonnet Echo back in the days.

Anthony H wrote:

I have a feeling the answer may lie in the drivers.

These are mature and do not fail elsewhere. Blaming the drivers will not bring your case forward.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Hello
I'd like to pick this up again, please - I am sure there is a solution or answer to be found. The year has been busy and I am only now finding time for investigating this again.

I have since tested the Multiface on a Win 7 machine which has an ExpressCard slot (this is the only machine I had access to). It performs perfectly. No glitchy pulses and no screeching whine, no crashing. I have also corresponded with Sonnet, sending them system reports etc, and their assessment is that the Sonnet is performing correctly over Thunderbolt - no errors detected. MacOS is able to recognise and access the Multiface. The RME HDSPe range, and specifically the Multiface II, is listed as tested and compatible in their compatibility listings https://www.sonnettech.com/support/char … egacy.html

The behaviour on my Macbook Pro remains problematic, though. The device connects, the Totalmix and HDSPe settings open up as expected. It is only when attempting to use the device (ie playback any audio, from any application, including the test function in Audio Midi Setup) that there is suddenly a massive problem. There is a pulsing buzz/click in the audio channels, which soon turns to a screeching whine with channels peaking way into the red (as in the screenshot posted above.) Soft disconnecting the I/O Box through the HDSPe Settings app has no effect. If I hot remove the ExpressCard, or unplug the Thunderbolt cable, the whining stops and the meters reset to zero (which is expected). If I immediately reinsert the card or plug in the Thunderbolt cable, macOS recognises the Multiface and it is immediately available as an audio device again BUT this time there is no audio at all. No pulsing or whining - no activity on any channels. If I restart the machine, I will experience the pulsing/whining again.

I am running Soundsource and can see audio activity on those meters when I play an audio file which matches what I would expect to see when playing that file, so there is indeed normal audio activity within macOS. But either there is pulsing/whining or nothing is happening after a re-connect as described. The pulsing/whining has zero correlation to the audio being played. I have tested with and without Soundsource running and it makes no difference (in fact, I only installed Soundsource after this problem was first encountered.)

These are the current details in the HDSPe Settings on macOS:
RME HDSPe/AES/RayDAT/AIO/MADIface
Mac OSX Driver 4.24
Multiface (22766171), Rev 20

TotalMix FX is ver 1.83 macOS (1)

This may be important - the original power supply failed and I am using a 3rd party supply. Bearing in mind that the Multiface is working perfectly on the Win 7 machine with this same power supply, could there be something problematic on the power front when connecting via the Sonnet & Thunderbolt which would cause these symptoms?

Thanks.

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

In the Audio-Midi-Setup what is shown as Format ?
can you change the sample rate there ? Has it an influence to the noise issue ?

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

waedi wrote:

In the Audio-Midi-Setup what is shown as Format ?
can you change the sample rate there ? Has it an influence to the noise issue ?

Sample rate is set to 48k normally in my setup. I can change this setting in Audio Midi Setup and in HSDPe settings - if I change one, the other changes automatically.

This time around the following is happening, the error is triggered and I get the screeching whine. If I soft disconnect the I/O box in the HDSPe Settings it stops. If I reconnect it continues. But, if I disconnect, then change the sample rate, when I reconnect the whining remains stopped until I play back audio then it happens again. Disconnect -> change sample rate -> reconnect, it is silent -> play audio, it screams. I've tried every sample rate from 32k to 96k.

I am also noticing now that when this happens, it seems to be always spiking at various levels in the SPDIF and/or ADAT channels, and creating a whine in the analog 1/2 outputs. There is nothing connected to the SPDIF or ADAT (in fact, I have disconnected the monitors completely to avoid damaging them with the noise - I've just got headphones plugged in to have some form of monitoring.

And just now I noticed visible glitches in the HDSPe UI and on my desktop.

I cannot install the latest driver revision (4.25) because the installer crashes on opening. But I don't see anything in the release notes which would make a difference. I wonder if rolling back to an earlier driver would help?

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

As long the computer has connection to the card I would try to perform a flash update of the firmware with the FUT.

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

I've just tested something else: I can run live audio (guitar with DI box) into the analog inputs and it performs normally. The input is visible on the totalmix meters, and audible through headphone and analog output monitoring if I route to the analog outputs using the matrix.

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

waedi wrote:

As long the computer has connection to the card I would try to perform a flash update of the firmware with the FUT.

I'm sure i did a flash update earlier this year. Yes, the expresscard is to version 20 according to HDSPe Settings->About. It also says something about Driverkit and version 21, but I don't know what that means. Is there no firmware update for the I/O Box itself?

I'm looking at the products page now and notice it says Multiface but not Multiface II.

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

That means the issue is only on the software playback channels ?

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

waedi wrote:

That means the issue is only on the software playback channels ?

Yes it does suggest that's the case. It's in the software playback channels that these spikes are happening, particularly in the digital and optical outs which I've never used and aren't connected.

19 (edited by waedi 2024-12-14 13:50:13)

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Your Totalmix version is 1.83, the actual version is 1.97
you can download Totalmix separate and replace the old one.

https://forum.rme-audio.de/viewtopic.ph … 26#p223726

Scroll down to the download link for Mac

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Okay, so I installed TM 1.97 (which looks like it's in beta?)

After that, I hit play and had the same massive output spike on numerous channels. A loud CLICK/FUZZ pulse for a few seconds, then a high pitched whine/sine wave. Then my machine backed out into the login screen, and hung with the beachball of doom. I disconnected the expresscard but that didn't help and had to do a hard power button shutdown. Did a system reset when rebooting.

Now, plugged the expresscard back in. HDSPe and TM open up, it's the 1.97 version. Playing back an audio file now does nothing at all. No massive spikes, but also no audio. Analog in and out still work as before. Playing back the audio using the built-in audio does work.

I've also noticed the Mutliface II is very hot. I can't recall if that's normal.

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Well that seems to have made things worse, actually. I restarted and tried audio playback again. Now the machine instantly reboots to the "Your computer restarted" screen. It's happened twice in a row and I don't want to keep doing it because it may damage the laptop and/or OS. The TM window again shows spikes mostly (if not only) in the ADAT and SPDIF channels. I can't take a screenshot because the laptop basically freezes and it's gone.

Would it make sense to try roll back the drivers, flash the card with an older version? I don't understand the Driverkit method - is this something to be tried?

No one has commented on the power supply, so I assume this is not an issue, especially seeing that it works on the Win 7 machine.

I'm only managing to investigate this in my spare time, which is limited. I really appreciate your replies!

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

I didn't manually change the Startup Security policy before installing the drivers, or running the firmware updates. Could this be causing a problem?

If necessary to reinstall everything, do I need to follow a procedure to completely remove the current installations or can I just install again?

23 (edited by waedi 2024-12-16 12:41:44)

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Only install the 425 driver. It will do all the work. Just follow the readme text file.

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

waedi wrote:

Only install the 425 driver. It will do all the work. Just follow the readme text file.

I'll do that....as soon as I've figured out this reduced startup security step. I've followed the steps given for Intel macs but i don't seem to have that security option in the recovery mode like they show. It's a slightly older macbook pro. Mid 2014. Not sure if that makes a difference. I was previously using this multiface II without any problems on a 2011 mbp

25 (edited by waedi 2024-12-17 19:34:45)

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

It is possible your computer / MacOS doesn't have this security feature and the driver will work as is.
Try install and reboot.

M1-Sequoia, Madiface Pro, Digiface USB, Babyface silver and blue

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

waedi wrote:

It is possible your computer / MacOS doesn't have this security feature and the driver will work as is.
Try install and reboot.

I've got it working and am over the moon to have this interface up and running! The 4.25 driver didn't work at all. The unit didn't even connect after installing that. So I rolled back to an earlier version, double checked the security settings (indeed, it turns out the security steps are not implemented the same on all Intel Macs as depicted in RMEs instruction video), and hey presto!

I want to thank you for your responses - I sincerely appreciate that you've taken time to offer input and help.

@MC It was the drivers after all...

27

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

4.25 works here and there is no reason it shouldn't. One issue might be that you still have the KE driver running in the background, the other that you flashed the wrong firmware - 4.24 and 4.25 are DK and need firmware 21, with 20 the driver does not find the interface.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

The DK is listed as for MacOS12 - so I haven't used it. I am using KE 4.24 with firmware 20. 4.25 is available as a KE extension driver for MacOS 11 and up, and didn't work - firmware 20 is listed as the latest for KE drivers, and this is what is flashed. It was only after installing KE 4.25, then rolling back to KE 4.24 that the problem was resolved.

The bottom line is that the problem/solution lay in the drivers, as I suspected. And if I hadn't persisted, I wouldn't be using an RME interface today.

https://i.ibb.co/ZdZTPFB/Screenshot-2024-12-20-at-11-11-15.png

29

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

> The DK is listed as for MacOS12

Where do you see that? I see:

macOS 11 or up HDSPe Series Kernel Extension Driver, 2024-10-18, driver_hdspe_mac_425.zip
Version 4.25, for macOS 11 and up. Supports Intel and Mx. See readme for installation notes.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

MC wrote:

> The DK is listed as for MacOS12

Where do you see that? I see:

macOS 11 or up HDSPe Series Kernel Extension Driver, 2024-10-18, driver_hdspe_mac_425.zip
Version 4.25, for macOS 11 and up. Supports Intel and Mx. See readme for installation notes.

Thats the Kernel Extension driver, not the DK.

https://i.ibb.co/D4wx4mp/Untitled.png

31

Re: Multiface 2 via Sonnet to Macbook Pro - no audio

Ok, I just saw in the first post that you are still on Big Sur aka 11. Didn't notice that.

Regards
Matthias Carstens
RME